The Jersey Gaze / 2026 - United Out Loud
Encountering Opposition

The first time I went to a board of education meeting, I was sure that I was about to engage in meaningful, systemic, allyship. During my training as a therapist, we’d been taught that it was an ethical responsibility to advocate, to use our privilege to educate others and influence meaningful policy changes. I went prepared to read testimony supporting the rights of trans youth in schools- what I had not anticipated was encountering loud, brazen, opposition. I was ill prepared and ill equipped, that first encounter, to hear painfully outdated rhetoric and hate. Even now, on occasion, I feel underprepared to interact with opposition, and I’d like to offer a few thoughts to allies, cis and trans alike, as you navigate taking on the responsibilities of responding (or not) to folks who rally against our rights.
When I think about key topics that people in opposition to trans rights bring up, three main areas come to mind: protecting children, women’s sports, and restrooms. Engaging in conversation with folks who are unsympathetic to trans issues can be frustrating at best, but these three topics are in my experience the most wrought with misinformation and disinformation, leading to the most challenging conversations to entertain. A common pitfall I find with these topics is that of fact checking. It is not to say that facts and true information are not important and necessary to debunking harmful ideas (I encourage all allies to read books and engage with content by trans and gender diverse creators to better understand the facts.) However, thanks to the Internet and simple access to modern medical consensus, it is easier than ever to fact check sweeping false claims about schools performing surgeries and “men” dominating women’s sports. What I intend to point out is that when a person against trans rights is engaging in conversation with you, what is keeping them from support is not lack of information, but rather is a lack of understanding of mutual humanity.
Most people have gender-neutral restrooms in their homes. Most people receive some kind of gender affirming care in their lifetime, from testosterone supplements to treat low libido, hair transplants, breast augmentations and reductions, to hormone therapy to treat symptoms of menopause. Even hormone blockers, often debated by anti-trans opposition, were developed for cisgender and intersex children who were suffering from precocious (unusually early) puberty. Yet, many cisgender people see themselves as belonging to a different category of person than trans people. Their understanding is that they are not themselves experiencing gender. I believe this disconnect causes some cis people to be unsympathetic of trans folks.

Rather than being persuaded by facts, I posit that what these folks may actually need is to humanize both trans people and themselves. They need to be listened to before listening. To be heard in their fears of being left behind by progress and misunderstanding, and once they feel safe, to be lovingly brought to understanding. This is no small task, and it cannot be achieved in one conversation. Many people who reject the reality that trans people exist are rejecting the idea that they may not understand the world as clearly as they thought they did. It can be scary and disorienting to realize that you know less than you thought you knew.
I do not expect you to suddenly hold space for every person with anti-trans views, nor do I expect you to know how to navigate every conversation. What I hope for you is that you can begin to step back and recognize that a goal in some of these interactions is not to prove that you are right – it is to show folks who are locked in a narrow view of the world that you can still see their humanity and that trans people share that same humanity.
I am, of course, not speaking to every interaction with opposition. This is often not viable, and many times, is unrealistic. In situations where physical or psychological safety are at risk, it may not be possible to hold space for a person, especially not as a queer or trans person whose identity is being debated or challenged. If, however, you are not in danger or are in a position where you might be able to use your privilege or power, I encourage you to start small. Begin with someone you know. Begin with someone you love. Help connect them to mutual humanity and to find the through lines that help us relate to and care for each other.

